Free Shipping on Orders Over $ 100 *
Customer Service|Privacy insurance policy
Enter your email to sign up for our newsletter and save 25% on your next order
Beef and dairy products have receive a fair amount of repercussion within the last decade or so . We have been recite that boeuf is a big proponent in the increase of obesity and other chronic diet - connect diseases , as well as dramatic environmental damage . However , more and more multitude are speaking out that this is not the case .
The followers is an except fromDefending Beefby Nicolette Hahn Niman . It has been adapted for the web .
We ’ve all heard the narrative so often — the one about how violent meat , beef in particular , is killing us — that many of us have come to accept it as incontrovertible the true . It ’s so common it ’s coarse cognition . The story goes something like this :
Americans once raise cattle , slovenly person , and sheep on small , mixed farm dust around the country , sprinkled with handfuls of livestock . Animal numbers were scurvy and , correspondingly , Americans ate dainty dowery of animate being fat and red meat . We were thin . Hypertension , stroke , and heart disease rates were low-spirited . Environmental wrong from farming was minimal . Over the course of the twentieth hundred , however , everything change for the worse . farm animal herds inflate . Cattle overgrazed . Red marrow and animal fat became abundant , garish , and ubiquitous . Americans gorged themselves on hamburger , butter , and ice rink cream . The result : soil eating away , water and melody befoulment , and skyrocketing rates of corpulency and inveterate diet - related disease .
Yes , function are correct . But facts that rarely make it into mainstream discussions and culture medium reportage diametrically oppose the narrative ’s key elements . As this leger will make clear , aspects of the United States ’ environmental stipulation have , indeed , aggravate , and chronic dieting - related diseases have become more far-flung and severe . Butthese problems can not reasonably be connected with bovine , butter , or beef . Why ?
Because there are about the same telephone number of cows on the res publica today as there were a hundred ago . Andwhile Americans are claim in more calories overall , they are eating less red meat in general , and less beef cattle in particular , than at any time in late history . We are also eat up less butter , far less whole Milk River , and much less pure fauna fat . No swell up bovid herds . No ever - heftier portion of crimson meat or squawk avoirdupois . From these facts alone , the simplistic narrative tumble .
If you are skeptical , I wo n’t fault you . What I ’ve just said likely run counter to what you ’ve heard from various beginning for many years . But I hail armed with data , and mickle of it , all from prescribed government sources . While my overall premises — thatcattle are good for the environment and that boeuf , butter , and cheeseflower are healthy nutrient — are , admittedly , controversial in this day and age , the canonical farming and demographic facts are not in dispute .
Here is the most pertinent point to keep in psyche . In the second one-half of this playscript , I will detail how American diets have changed . I will showwe eat less beef and less animal adipose tissue now than we did 100 years ago , while our consumption rate for sugar , metric grain , and industrial vegetable oil color have skyrocketed . I will present fact powerfully supporting the decision thatour sugar , flour , and veg oil consumption rather than cerise meat and creature adipose tissue are to find fault for the crisp rise in fleshiness and continuing diseases .
The pop story line is also far off - stem refer the numbers of fauna on the land . In reality , Americans ’ eating substance abuse have shifted away from boeuf toward poultry and Pisces the Fishes . Decreasing per - capita phthisis of bitch has been accompanied by a decline in per capita cattle in US inventory . It ’s rightful the total measure of blood-red meat and dairy farm produced has increase as our universe has get , and some is exported . But the amount of bitch and dairy the United States exports is really quite little . Only about 7 percent and 2 percent , severally , go to foreign market . So kine set up for exported kernel and Milk River merchandise barely affect the math .
gravid output in the bitch and dairy sectors has really not resulted from swell up herd sizes . On the marrow side , this is because brute are now slaughtered at much vernal ages . At the aurora of the 20th century , a distinctive beef confidential information was charge to slaughter at four or five years of age1 . Today , to down costs , and enabled by cereal feeding and emergence hormones , that steer is vote down younger than two year former , typically around 14 months.2Dairy cows , too , go to massacre at much new ages ( often just three years sure-enough ) . This also impress beef supply because , now , as always , a orotund portion of US bitch comes from dairy farm Bos taurus .
The wage increase in Milk River production , however , is owing to another military issue . As I detail in my bookRighteous Porkchop , selective breeding of dairy kine for bang-up milk outturn ( read : large bodies and Brobdingnagian udders ) has immensely increase per - animal production.3At the beginning of the twentieth century , mediocre US yearly per - moo-cow Milk River turnout was 2,902 pound ( 348 gallon ) . Today it is 22,774 Lebanese pound ( 2,734 gallons ) per year . This is often vaunt as a major triumph for humanity . But the scurf of the increase ( more than sevenfold ) suggestsselective breeding has been pushed to an extreme point . ( Indeed , many of today ’s mature dairy cows even have trouble walk , something I have in person witnessed , with heavy heart , numerous time . ) The net force of this change has been a substantial shrinking of the US dairy farm ruck over the retiring hundred .
For those of you who may still observe this gruelling to consider , here are the specific figure . Since 1900 , kick cattle numbers rose , but less than people incline to assume , going from 67 million to 94 million . Pig number have also gone up , but not much : In 1920 , there were 60 million sloven ; in 2018 , 74 million . On the other hand , sheep Book of Numbers plummeted , go from a high of 46 million in 1940 to 5 million today . Likewise , the dairy cow ruck shrivel dramatically , from 32 million down to 9 million , over the past hundred . And draft animals have run from 22 million in 1900 to just 3 million in 2002 . All separate , that means that while early-20th - one C farm and cattle farm had rough 99 million straits of Bos taurus and 227 million larger animals ( including Bos taurus ) , today they have 103 million cattle and 185 million larger beast . That ’s a low 4 percent gain in Bos taurus numbers and an overall 19 percentreductionin large farm animals .
From an environmental standpoint , two issues are most relevant : How many animals are in stock , and , more significant , by what methods are they being raised ? These factors will largely determine ecological footprint — harmful or helpful . As we ’ve just seen , there are only slightly more cattle today than for much of the past century . At the same time , cattle are being raised with more fear : There is a burgeoning movement within Department of Agriculture to thoughtfully manage grazing . This is increasingly translate animate being impact into a groundwork of regenerative USDA .
From a diet and human health perspective , the central questions are : What ’s being consumed , and in what form ? Are we eating real , whole , unprocessed vegetables , fruits , crank , grains , bollock , Pisces , and meats or , in demarcation , “ edible food - like substances , ” as Michael Pollan calls them in his bookFood Rules?Americans today consume less squawk and butter but far more processed intellectual nourishment . Fast food , box bite , and sweet-flavored drinks for newbie . We all know a bowl of spud chips is junk food for thought whereas a sunbaked potato is satiating and nourishing . Similarly , a mass - produced raging dog is wholly different from a steak .
It ’s substantive to recognise these fact when we talk about meat . If we pick out that total cattle number have been fairly unchanging and beef intake is down , it immediately cast serious doubt on the all - too - common story that fault cattle and gripe for our current environmental and public wellness crisis . I would not have a bun in the oven these fact , on their own , to dissolve the concern of kick ’s critic . But I hope clarifying these head at the offset will allow reader to consider this Christian Bible with an open mind .
I powerfully dispute the charge that cattle and boeuf are responsible for the globe ’s environmental and human health problems . But aspects of the popular narrative I mention at the get-go are right , and they need quick and free burning attention . Serious environmental debasement the world over has been triggered by agriculture , including the kine and beef sectors . Like much of American agriculture , the beef cattle industry has become too pendent on manmade inputs like insecticides , fertiliser , hormone , and other pharmaceuticals . Until just the retiring few years , there has also been far-flung failure to grasp dirt biology as the essential foundation of truly regenerative land . Many involve in mainstream farming , including those raise cattle , have give out to prioritize generating nutrient - racy , health - sustaining human foods . Simply put , industrialisation has radically altered the way humans grow and eat , much of it for the worse . These issues will be explored in this rule book .
This leger is at once a defense mechanism of oxen and beef , and an bill of indictment of aspects of modern farming and diets . Change in both arenas is urgently needed . The United States is the Earth ’s top beef producer.4We can , andshould , lead the globe in work style of levy cattle that override environmental degradation and produce healthy , alimentary - rich intellectual nourishment .
For me , it amount down to this : Cattle are central to the human floor . We have lived alongside them for ten-spot of thousands of years . Our snug connective with kine has boosted our trunk ’ immunity , enabled our migration , and provided us with intensely nourishing , delicious food . Done with maintenance , oxen farming enriches our human experience and enhances the raw world . We must move well beyond simplistic solution like ban cattle from our landscape and beef and butter from our plate . Instead , it ’s clock time to focus on ameliorate how we lift cattle and turn them into food . Only then can we tap into the full bionomical and nourishment potential these remarkable creatures allow for . As my ally Russ Conser has said , “ It ’s not thecow , it ’s thehow . ”
Whether you are among the critics or the defenders of squawk , if you come along on this journeying , you will recover things to harmonise and disagree with along the way . Whatever your perspective at the start , I hope by the end you will see things in a Modern and dissimilar light .
Notes
1 . R. R. Snapp , Beef Cattle : Their Feeding and Management in the Corn Belt States , tertiary ed . ( Wiley & Sons , 1939 ) , 16 .
2 . See N. Hahn Niman , Righteous Porkchop : chance a Life and Good Food Beyond Factory Farms(HarperCollins , 2009 ) , chapter 7 , “ Beef , the Most ( below the belt ) Maligned of substance . ”
3 . Hahn Niman , Righteous Porkchop , chapter 8 , “ The ( Un)-Sacred Milk Cow . ”
4 . The United States is really fourth ( after India , Brazil , and China ) in the number of Bos taurus , but it produces the most beef . BEEF Magazine , August 13 , 2013 , beefmagazine .com / cattle - industry - social system / industry - glance - beef cattle - cow - stock - over - fourth dimension .
Recommended Reads
Why oxen are the Premier Dairy Choice
All About cow : What has Four Legs , enounce “ Moo , ” and Could carry through the Planet ?
Defending Beef
The Ecological and Nutritional Case for Meat , 2nd Edition
$ 17.95
Recent Articles
Foraging 101: Where to find your bounty
Do n’t have it away where to get down for foraging crazy plants ? Read on for the info you need to begin scrounge on your own : where to do it and how to be secure .
Farming Against Nature
When you ’re walking around the foodstuff memory looking at the veg , it ’s probably hard to imagine that a century ago there was twice the amount of options .
Zesty & Simple: New Classic Rainbow Coleslaw
Easy rainbow coleslaw ! Transform your salad game with this coloured recipe . It is surprisingly mob with flavor and is a outstanding gain to your repertory .
Types of Tomatoes: Deciphering the Many Varieties
If you love tomatoes , you probably already be intimate just how many varieties of these summertime staples there are . But do you know what make each one unequalled ?
Foraging for Mushrooms: Gourmet Root Systems
For mass who enjoy forage for food in the wild , there are plenty of mushroom to choose from — “ ten thousand mushroom-shaped cloud mintage to be deliberate on the North American continent alone ” . But foraging for mushrooms should never be call up of as a game of opportunity . You need to have a go at it all the clues when it comes to identifying …
© 2025 Rizzoli International Publications Inc. All Rights Reserved .
Rizzoli International Publications300 Park Avenue South , 4th FloorNew York , NY 10010United state
There are items in your basket which are ready to ship.
You ’ll take to checkout before tally this pre - order item to your basket .
